Independent Acne Comparison

Find acne treatments that match your skin – not just the loudest ads.

AcneHeals.com looks at real ingredients, strengths and routines – not just before/after photos. Use this page to compare popular acne products side by side and build a realistic routine.

  • See which products are strong, and which are barrier-friendly.
  • Match treatments to your acne type: spots, whiteheads, cysts, or maintenance.
  • Avoid common mistakes like doubling up on harsh actives.

This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Rankings are editorial and not for sale.

Top acne treatments – side by side

Ratings are based on a mix of formula strength, role in a routine, user feedback patterns and how easy they are to combine with other products. Stronger is not always better – it’s about the right strength for **your** skin and acne type.

Product Best for Type & strength Key notes Our rating
Proactiv 3-Step Acne Treatment Kit
Best complete starter routine
Moderate, persistent acne · Teens & adults Multi-step · Benzoyl peroxide system
Cleanser + treatment + moisturiser
Structured routine for people who want a “just follow the steps” approach.
Can be drying – barrier-friendly moisturiser and sunscreen are essential.
★★★★★
4.5 / 5 strength-to-results
Price band: $$
View kit on Amazon
Paula’s Choice CLEAR Daily Skin Clearing Treatment (Benzoyl Peroxide)
Best benzoyl peroxide for routines
Inflammatory spots · Routine users Leave-on benzoyl peroxide treatment
Designed to layer under moisturiser
Great “workhorse” treatment for people already using a gentle cleanser and moisturiser.
Use a pea-sized amount; start a few nights per week to avoid over-drying.
★★★★★
4.6 / 5 targeted control
Price band: $$
View treatment on Amazon
Neutrogena On-The-Spot Acne Spot Treatment (2.5% Benzoyl Peroxide)
Best focused spot treatment
Occasional breakouts · Add-on for existing routine 2.5% BPO · lower-strength spot gel
Dab on individual spots, not all over
Good option if you mostly need help with a few stubborn spots at a time.
Won’t replace a full routine if your acne is more widespread.
★★★★☆
4.3 / 5 targeted use
Price band: $
View spot treatment
Mighty Patch™ Original from Hero Cosmetics
Best “emergency” patch for whiteheads
Whiteheads · Night-time emergency fixes Hydrocolloid patch · non-medicated
Draws out fluid, protects from picking
Great for people who tend to pick – gives a physical barrier over active whiteheads.
Best as a supplement to a routine, not a full acne strategy on its own.
★★★★☆
4.5 / 5 “SOS” helper
Price band: $
View patches on Amazon
CeraVe Moisturising Lotion
Best barrier support
All skin types using actives · Barrier repair Fragrance-free moisturiser · ceramides
Non-comedogenic hydrating base
Not an “acne treatment” on its own – but vital if actives are drying or irritating.
Works well between benzoyl peroxide, retinoids and sunscreen in most routines.
★★★★★
4.8 / 5 barrier support
Price band: $
View lotion on Amazon
MDacne Acne Treatment Kits
Personalised kit option
People who want a guided, app-based routine Customised kit · multiple actives
App guidance + products
Good for people overwhelmed by building their own routine from scratch.
Always read the active ingredient list carefully before combining with other products.
★★★★☆
4.4 / 5 guided system
Price band: $$–$$$
View MDacne kits

*Prices, availability and exact formulations can change at any time. Always check the retailer’s page for the latest information. Ratings here are editorial opinions only and not medical advice.

How to choose the right mix for your skin

Think in terms of roles in a routine, not “one magic product”. Most people will need at least: a gentle cleanser, one leave-on treatment, a moisturiser and a daily sunscreen.

1. Decide how strong you really need to go

  • Mild acne / occasional breakouts: spot treatments + patches + gentle lotion may be enough.
  • Moderate acne: a structured routine like Proactiv or Paula’s Choice CLEAR makes more sense.
  • Severe, painful or scarring acne: talk to a dermatologist – prescriptions often work better and faster.

2. Protect your barrier first

Over-drying the skin is the fastest way to make acne, redness and stinging worse.

  • Pair any benzoyl peroxide or active kit with a barrier-friendly lotion (like CeraVe).
  • Introduce treatments a few nights per week, not all at once every day.
  • Use daily SPF – especially if you are using strong actives.

3. Don’t double up on the same strong active

If one product already has benzoyl peroxide or strong acids, layering more of the same can mean irritation without better results.

  • Pick one main benzoyl peroxide product at a time.
  • Combine with gentler steps (cleanser, moisturiser, SPF) instead of more harshness.

Example routines using products from this page

Routine A – Occasional breakouts

  • Cleanser: gentle, non-stripping cleanser you already like.
  • Targeted treatment: Neutrogena On-The-Spot on individual blemishes.
  • Emergency nights: Mighty Patch over whiteheads to avoid picking.
  • Moisturiser: CeraVe Moisturising Lotion to keep barrier calm.

Routine B – Moderate, ongoing acne

  • Full system: Proactiv 3-Step Kit or MDacne kit (not both).
  • Extra moisture: Add CeraVe Moisturising Lotion if skin feels tight or dry.
  • Emergency helper: Mighty Patch when specific spots come to a head.

Routine C – Ingredient-curious, wants control

  • Cleanser: gentle, low-foam cleanser.
  • Main treatment: Paula’s Choice CLEAR as your benzoyl peroxide step.
  • Spot help: Neutrogena On-The-Spot on individual stubborn blemishes.
  • Barrier: CeraVe Moisturising Lotion + daily mineral/chemical SPF.

These example routines are general ideas, not personalised treatment plans. Always patch test new products and talk to your own doctor or dermatologist about severe or long-lasting acne.